My Kind of Stupid

Web development, user interfaces, and other development topics.

ActiveRecord Hangs On to Destroyed Relations

Rails' ActiveRecord has a nifty #destroy method that almost everyone already knows about. The documentation for #destroy1 helpfully states

Deletes the record in the database and freezes this instance to reflect that no changes should be made (since they can’t be persisted).

What is less clear is how it works when you call it on a relationship. To be sure, it destroyed the database record. What it also unfortunately does it hangs on to the reference in the parent object.

Let's throw down with some sample code.

class Thing < ActiveRecord::Base
  has_one :child

class Child < ActiveRecord::Base
  belongs_to :thing

zengarden> thing =
=> #<Thing id: nil, name: nil, created_at: nil, updated_at: nil>
=> true
zengarden> thing.create_child :name => "Child"
=> #<Child id: 4, name: "Child", thing_id: 1,...>
zengarden> thing.child
=> #<Child id: 4, name: "Child", thing_id: 1...>
zengarden> thing.child.destroy
=> #<Child id: 4, name: "Child", thing_id: 1...>
zengarden> thing.child
=> #<Child id: 4, name: "Child", thing_id: 1...>

Arg. I just destroyed it! I don't want it hanging around in my cache. If I really wanted to save it, I should have saved it before or during the destroy call. I can of course invalidate my cache by calling


which correctly returns nil. But if I don't know to do that immediately after the destroy, I get errors like

TypeError: can't modify frozen hash

because code used later naïvely calls

if thing.child
  thing.child.attributes = new_attributes

expecting that if a child exists, it should be updated.

For the sake of argument, let's say that maybe the behavior isn't so bad, maybe this is what people expect or could use. In that case, what a terrible error message. I'm not familiar enough with the Associations internals to suggest where a better one could be injected, but something along the lines of

Can't modify a destroyed record

would be miles better.

Published at